The Power of Feedback by Clive Howard

An exciting aspect of Create50 was the opportunity to get feedback from other writers. As a writer, I know well the value of feedback. That said, it can be very difficult to hear.


Despite several years of experience, I can still have a negative response to other people’s thoughts on my work – akin to someone criticising your child.


However, I have learned that feedback almost always makes the work better.

I believe that there are two important considerations with respect to feedback.

The first is that people can fear offending and so do not always give you their honest thoughts. Other writers tend to be more honest which is why Create50 is so great. I gave the first draft of my The Singularity 50 entry – “The Agency of Ellis” - to someone I know well for review.


Their initial comments were positive but I could tell there was something that they were holding back. With encouragement, they were more critical. As a result, I re-wrote the story – keeping the same characters, locations and the story’s soul – but the new version was significantly different. It was also much, much better.

The second is that there is often a degree of interpretation involved. Reviewers do not always mean exactly what they say. Sometimes one must read between the lines or delve deeper into their thoughts – being careful not to seem like you’re arguing the point. Reviewers can provide solutions rather than articulate the underlying issue – a little careful questioning can unearth the true problem. One must often balance different feedback that can sometimes seem contradictory.

I also find that reviewing other people’s work improves my own. By reading others one can learn and then apply those learnings to your own work. It helps to hone a critical eye which one can then use on your own work.

For these reasons, in addition to the fantastic opportunity to get work published, I found taking part in Singularity50 a great learning experience.


Clive Howard




Twitter: @clivehoward

Write a comment

Comments: 2
  • #1

    Susannah Heffernan (Monday, 03 July 2017 17:31)

    As an emerging author, the feedback during the Singularity 50 process has been enormously helpful. It has helped me edit and reflect, and has introduced me to a valuable range of sci-fi writing. Good luck to everyone in the selection over the coming months!

  • #2

    Chris Jones (Monday, 03 July 2017 21:29)

    Thanks for sharing and yes, GOOD LUCK!

Sign up to get updates about Singularity50...

and other Create50 Projects

By signing up you can expect to get messages about Create50 and associated courses, events, projects, launches and services. You can unsubscribe at any time and we can remove your data entirely from our systems. We use MadMimi (owned by GoDaddy) to host and deliver our email messages. You can read their data compliance and privacy policy HERE. If you would like help unsubscribing or being removed entirely from our systems, please drop us an email at You can read our full Privacy Policy HERE.

CONTACT US: Create50 Ltd., Ealing Studios, Ealing Green, London W5 5EP